Coalition of Groups Across the State to Governor’s office: veto GRAS Bill
November 4, 2026
The Honorable Kathy Hochul
New York State Capitol Building, Executive Chambers
Albany, NY 12224
Re: Opposition to Senate Bill S1239F
Dear Governor Hochul:
The coalition of companies and organizations represented here respectfully request your veto of Senate Bill S1239F.
Collectively, we represent New York and America’s food, beverage, ingredient, agriculture, business, retail, and hospitality industries. Our coalition members produce, source, manufacture, package, distribute, and sell safe and wholesome products in New York and across the United States. We employ thousands of New Yorkers and are committed to keeping our state an affordable place to live in and do business.
The United States has the safest, most efficient, and affordable food system in the world and the safety and quality of what we make and offer to consumers is of the highest importance. That is why all of us support a nationwide approach to food ingredient safety that is grounded in science and consistency for all. This legislation undermines the authority of the U.S. Food & Drug Administration (FDA) to effectively regulate the safety of the American food supply.
S1239F will only increase costs for New Yorkers and for the state with no corresponding improvement to food safety. It creates a redundant, New York-specific reporting requirement that imposes unnecessary bureaucracy despite existing federal standards that already ensure our safe food supply. No other state has implemented an extreme and costly mandate such as proposed by S1239F. For example, this year the California State Assembly declined to advance similar legislation due to its huge fiscal impact in that state. California legislative staff indicated that bill, like New York S1239F, would be so expensive that they could only estimate it would cost the state, ”an unknown amount, likely in the millions of dollars per year, ongoing.”
Recent studies show that duplicating existing federal oversight will cost $1.8 billion more to supply food and beverages to New Yorkers, costing the state $21 million in its first three years, and increasing grocery prices in the average New York household by approximately $620 per year.
These costs would extend beyond just shoppers as the State of New York is also a consumer and purchaser of food to support school meal programs, nutritional assistance programs, and institutional residence programs. The impact to eligible households in the Women, Infant, and Children program will be as much as $60 million per year due to additional burdens mandated in the legislation. It is not simply a matter of duplicating information already in hand.
This legislation will require the development of a new, unfunded public database. Costs to the state to manage and implement this enormous influx of data are estimated to be as much as $35 million and will necessitate additional staffing resources. None of this is necessary, as the FDA has announced a proposed rule on GRAS and Congressional legislation is pending; S1239F is unaligned with these efforts.
By creating two different regulatory standards for the food and beverage industry – one enforced by New York and one by the federal government – this legislation would inject additional costs into the food supply chain at a time when we should be doing all we can to bring affordability to consumers by lowering prices.
Governor Hochul, this legislation is unnecessary, harmful to New York businesses, will significantly raise grocery prices, and will not increase transparency or consumer safety.
On behalf of our organizations representing the entire spectrum of New York businesses, we respectfully yet strongly urge you to veto this expensive, misguided, and unnecessary legislation.
Sincerely,
American Bakers Association
American Beverage Association
Buffalo Niagara Manufacturing Alliance
American Chemistry Council
Buffalo Niagara Manufacturing Alliance
Business Council of New York
Calorie Control Council
Can Manufacturers Institute
Capital Region Chamber
CenterState CEO
Consumer Brands Association
Corn Refiners Association
Cortland Area Chamber of Commerce
Council for Responsible Nutrition
Edible Oil Producers Association
Flavor Extract Manufacturers Association
Flexible Packaging Association
FMI, The Food Industry Association
Food Industry Association of New York
Food Ingredient Safety Coalition
Greater Niagara Chamber of Commerce
Greater Rochester Chamber of Commerce
Independent Bakers Association
International Dairy Foods Association
International Food Additives Council
Korean American Business Council of Greater New York
Korean American Grocers Association of New York
Lake George Regional Chamber of Commerce and CVB
Meat Institute
National Confectioners Association
National Grocers Association
National Supermarket Association
New York Association of Convenience Stores
New York Economic Development Council
New York Farm Bureau
New York State Bottlers Association
New York State Restaurant Association
NFIB
Niagara USA Chamber of Commerce
Northeast Dairy Foods & Suppliers Associations
Northeast Dairy Producers Association, Inc.
North American Millers’ Association
North Country Chamber of Commerce
Partnership for New York City
Plastics Industry Association
Queens Chamber of Commerce
Rockland Business Association
SNAC International
*sponsored content*

